“That’s the thing of the Holy Spirit - you can try and explain it all away, but then there are somethings that have no explanation, that are mystical and perfect, things that no list in the world will make clear.....Life...exactly the same. Somethings are beyond our understanding.”
![]()
Coming Up for Air
by Patti Callahan Henry
copyright: 2011
publisher:St. Martin’s Press
format: ARC paperback
pages: 255
source: publisher
Goodreads Description: Ellie Calvin is caught in a dying marriage, and she knows this. With her beloved daughter away at college and a growing gap between her and her husband – between her reality and the woman she wants to be – she doesn’t quite seem to fit into her own life.
But everything changes after her controlling mother, Lillian, passes away.
First Sentence:
There are both wonderful and awful moments in a woman’s life.
My Thoughts: Coming Up for Air greatly satisfied. Ellie’s journey of emotions - truths and wishes - were beautifully written. Her life is a mess, and I was captivated. This is not a fluff read - plot may be simplistic but the real issues are not; there is depth. Many times throughout the story, the prose gave me moments of pause - to soak in the richness of thought, and to ponder the words. The pace of the story enabled Ellie’s journey to flow naturally; believability is felt with the path she takes, and choices she makes. Her interactions with those in her life are real felt, and meaningful. The unraveling of her mother’s past was fascinating and enlightening - I was incredibly intrigued. More than anything, the words “spoken” throughout this story are powerful, deep-rooted, real and passionate.
Bottom Line: I was greatly satisfied with this story: a nice mix between finding oneself, relationship navigation, and a touch of history. What keeps coming to mind is the beauty of the prose; the richness, and depth that gave me several moments of reflection. A moving story.
The cover: I think it is somewhat blah. I get the suburban suffocating feeling, but it does not spark interest for the story. The title suits the story well, but is somewhat lost with the author’s name.
Side Note: I LOVE it when I come away from a book with a very neat idea. An idea that I can implement into my own life. Within this story, a character keeps a journal. This journal is written in only once a year - every New Year’s Eve. It is a summary of the year (concise summary), and then goals/wishes for the following year are written. The goals/wishes from the previous year are checked to see if they came true or were met. A neat concept, and one that I can see myself doing starting this coming New Year’s Eve.
~~ I read, Coming Up for Air, last June/July. My impressions were written down on note cards which is my favorite method for drafting my thoughts. The note cards are stuffed into the book until I am ready to finalize my thoughts. When I finished reading this book, an idea for a re-read surfaced. The prose was such that I feel I could loose myself into the story yet again. I still feel this way several months removed from my first reading.
~~ I do not read too many contemporary fiction novels, and when I do, I want to be utterly and thoroughly swept into the story. Yes, that is true for all books that I read, but even more so with contemporary fiction. Reason being, the stories are “real world”, “real time” and I do not always care too much to read about “real time” life events. Not only that, I critique far too much; questioning the realism/believability of the story. For me, it is hard for a contemporary book to swept me into the story, because far too often, I am left sighing with dis-interest. Or, I was not drawn in as it was too mushy, weird, or off the beaten path. Simply put, the story was not realistic; it was cheesy. Due to my harsh leanings, it takes a good contemporary story - prose and plot - to satisfy.
Note worthy Quotes:
“we make our choices and then we live with them. Everyone does.” p.6
“My need for Hutch had once been rooted deeply into my bones so that I’d felt the desire not as a part of me, but as me completely.” p.12
“with every wish fulfilled there is something lost.” p. 24
“Love is not wanting and needing; it is knowing you would give your life for the other in a way that is absolute. It is knowing that there is not a day that will ever go by - for the rest of your life - when that person will not be on your mind or in your heart.” p. 160
“...that’s a choice everyone has. They can wish for what they want in their life or they can face the truth, but sometimes you can’t have both.” p.206
Giveaway: In light of my desire to make room on my bookshelves; I am offering this book to anyone who would like to read it. Impromptu giveaway - leave a comment stating that you would like to receive this book. If more than one person requests the book, I will randomly draw numbers. I will leave this giveaway open until December 8th. If no one requests the book, then on my shelves it will stay – for now.


