Meshing of Minds Review introduction:
My friend, Jody, and I love to talk books. Probably a week has not gone by that we have not had at least one book related conversation. While I do like reading children’s literature, I tend to lean towards adult reads such as historical fiction and fantasy. Jody leans towards children’s literature but will also read adult books that spark my interest. The most fun we have is when we read the same book and talk up a storm about a character, storyline, whatever. Since we do find great enjoyment talking books whether we agree or not, we decided that it would be great fun to blog our thoughts…to mesh our minds. We hope that you, dear reader, will find our “meshing of minds” review style interesting and enlightening as we present to you several books throughout the year in area of children’s literature as well as adult literature. For our reviews, we have decided to add a spoiler page which will be linked to the end of our main review post. Please, if you have read the book reviewed, check out the spoiler page. Regardless if you have read the book or not, please comment with your thoughts. We love conversation and would love to strike one up with you.
I am thrilled to announce, Jody is starting a book blog. Yay!! I am seriously excited about this. I love Jody’s take on things and I think you will too. Her blog, Bery Picking, is brand new and will focus on Newbery Medal winners, and other great reads. I am psyched and want to encourage Jody to share her book thoughts when she can manage it in her schedule. Please check out her introduction post, and help me welcome her to the book blogging community. I look forward to reading posts at Bery Picking.
When You Reach Me
by Rebecca Stead
Copyright 2009
Pages 197
2010 Newbery Medal Winner
Inside Flap:
By sixth grade, Miranda and her best friend, Sal, know how to navigate their New York City neighborhood. They know where it’s safe to go, like the local grocery store, and they know whom to avoid, like the crazy guy on the corner.
But things start to unravel. Sal gets punched by a new kid for what seems like no reason, and he shuts Miranda out of his life. The apartment key that Miranda’s mom keeps hidden for emergencies is stolen. And then Miranda finds a mysterious note scrawled on a tiny slip of paper:
I am coming to save your friend’s life, and my own.
I must ask two favors. First, you must write me a letter.
The notes keep coming, and Miranda slowly realizes that whoever is leaving them knows all about her, including things that have not even happened yet. Each message brings her closer to believing that only she can prevent a tragic death. Until the final note makes her think she’s too late.
First Sentence:
So Mom got the postcard today.
JODY
---------
As you know, Deanna, I’m a bit of a Newbery Geek. I have been for years. When I heard that Rebecca Stead, this year’s Newbery winner, was coming to a bookstore nearby, I jumped at the opportunity to go and meet her. I went having not read any of her books - this is only her second. I was skeptical that an author with such little writing experience with published children’s novels could be selected for such an esteemed award. I was also skeptical because I’m a title girl - a title has to grab me - and I thought this title was well, blah. I had also looked at the cover of WYRM and I was equally unimpressed. It looked like random objects placed on a childish drawing of a map. The title and the cover definitely did not appeal to me. And the back of the book did not meet my expectations either. When I pick up a book, I look at the title and cover art, then, I flip it over and read the back. I expect those 3 things to give me a feel for the book. The back of the hardcover edition of WYRM has “Praise for First Light” on the back. I don’t want to pick up a book and read about how great a different book is. I want to read about the book in my hand. Yes, the inside flap of the jacket did have the summary I was looking for. However, had it not been selected for the Newbery, I don’t think I ever would have picked the book up. How about you? What was your initial impression of the cover and title?
DEANNA
--------------
Ahh, yes Jody, you are a bit of a Newbery Geek. I say that with love. Anyhow, I never thought of myself as a Newbery reader. I actually considered myself as a very limited Newbery Medal or Honor book reader. I realized recently that I am being drawn to Newbery Medal or Honor books and have read more than I originally thought.
My initial thoughts about the book title, cover, and summary was not much beyond the fact that it won the medal and I know you are reading all the Newbery Medal books. Then you read the book, and was rather excited about the story. I promised that I would read the book, but told you that it would not happen before May which was true. So, I did not give the book title or cover much thought because I already knew you would read it, and then I knew you liked it so I knew then I would most definitely read it regardless. You have yet to lead me astray, and When You Reach Me did not make an exception.
Generally speaking though, titles and covers are not deal makers or breakers for me as they can be for you, but back cover summaries are huge for me, but even with that, I am not as picky as you because I am okay if the summary is on the inside flap. With that said, I do like my titles to make some sense in regards to the story, and I do believe, after reading this story, the title When You Reach Me makes great sense. The covers, yes, in general, the more appealing a cover the quicker my attention is gained. However, I would prefer a simple cover over a flashy trendy type cover, but wretched covers tend to always make me wonder what the publishers were thinking. As you know, my most favorite series has very simple covers for which I greatly like. I’d rather have a simple cover to let my own imagination take over rather than have a preconceived idea of the story. Covers with a model face already gives an “image” of a character, and I tend to not care too much for that but am still not bothered. The cover with When You Reach Me, I will agree, is not an attention grabber, and does make the story look rather dull for which it is not, but again, once done with read the cover makes sense.
I read Rebecca Stead’s first book, First Light, before I read When You Reach Me, and I really liked the story. I have to admit, I was very much blown away by the change of her writing with WYRM. It seems to me that she went from a straight-forth storyteller to one whose imagination had my brain guessing, thinking, twisting the whole way through the story. The mental work-out that I went through with the story was simply amazing. When done reading, I was immensely satisfied and blown away by the quality of literature I had just read, and I am an adult - meaning that I left the read wondering if that maybe...possibly...I am dunce because, with this middle-grade read, I did not see the ending nor the plot turns come my way. I felt like a dunce, wondering, if I did not see all the twist and turns, did children grasp what I did not during the story? I felt better knowing that you felt pretty much the same because I view you as an intelligent, and analytical adult. What were your first thoughts when you finished the read?
JODY
--------- When I finished the book, I was blown away! The story itself was so simple. A good story that moved along at a nice pace. It was easy to understand and a thoroughly enjoyable read. The storyline was simple in that there were not too many characters to keep straight or complicated time-lines to keep track of. There were basically two stories to follow... Miranda’s life at home and her life with her friends. Both were easy to follow and intermingled nicely.
Rebecca Stead, however, did an amazing job weaving an element of mystery through the entire story. The mystery did not overtake the story; it was woven into the storyline seamlessly creating a curiosity that would not allow me to put the book down. I finished the book in one sitting - it was impossible to stop reading it.
The simplicity of the mystery is the reason that the end of the story blew me away. Simple signs that pointed to the solution were hidden because they fit into the story so well. Events that were easily overlooked in the first read of the book ended up being significant in solving the mystery. I finished the book and instantly wanted to read it again. I wanted to look for the clues that I had missed. I wanted to read it the second time like a detective, looking for the every sign that I had missed during the first read. When I finished the book, I sat there in total appreciation of Stead’s talent as a writer. Never before have I seen such a complex story written so simply without confusing the reader or leaving lingering questions. Everything came together in the end to make me realize that I had just read a puzzle that put itself together. I didn’t have to put the pieces together, they just magically joined together through Stead’s amazing storytelling. And in the end, I looked at the puzzle and just said, “WOW!”
I think the simplicity of the story makes it a perfect read for late elementary and up.
You mention a “mental workout,” “intelligence,” and “analytical” thinking in regards to reading this book. Do you think the “average” kid would get it or do you think only a “gifted” or older kid would understand it? Along those same lines, do you think being set in the 70’s and The $20,000 Pyramid references will make the story unrelatable for kids today who have no familiarity with that decade? I guess what I’m asking is, do you think the story is too complex or too foreign for today’s youth?
DEANNA
--------------
The story is set in the 70’s and yes, the $20,000 Pyramid show is referenced many times, but would these factors make it hard for today’s youth to relate to the story? I don’t think so. I think that Rebecca Stead did a great job with the setting without making that the focus point. In other words, the storyline is about Miranda, her life at home and with her friends which gives familiarity to all, regardless of the times they are growing up. But, to be sure, I asked EJ, my 11-year old daughter, this question since she read the book.
EJ stated, “No, they did not make it hard, but because Miranda lives in a city and had a job, it was difficult to relate because I don’t live in the city, and kids don’t have jobs at that age. Still, those things did not make it difficult for me to understand Miranda.”
I used the words “mental workout”, “intelligence”, and “analytical” because that is how I felt about this story once I was *done* reading not *while* I was reading because it was simple story as you stated above. The story arc was easy to follow as well as interesting. I was curious throughout the read, and most definitely wanted to understand a few things, for instance, who was sending Miranda the notes?
I do think this story is attainable for children age 10 and up. I do not think a child needs to be “gifted” in order to read, and enjoy this story because the complexity of the story with the clues are not overwhelming; they are subtly woven throughout the story. Once the story has ended, the reader will most likely say, “Oh yeah, I didn’t see that coming... How cool!” Then, I do hope the child will like the story well enough to re-read it at some point in time, and then during that reading will gain a greater appreciation for the complexity of the simple story.
OVERALL
Jody and I both loved this story. We were both blown away by the author’s ability to create a complex yet simple story. When finished, we both thought... “WOW!”
When You Reach Me is a book that I am glad resides on my bookshelves. This is a book that I want all my children to read, at some point. And, one day, my grandchildren.
This is a book that calls out for a re-read, and after our initial meshing of minds review, we re-read the story.
The spoiler page discussion between Jody and I will concentrate on our re-read thoughts. If you have already read this fabulous book, please read our re-read thoughts, let us know what you think. If you have not already read this book, why are you waiting?
To discuss the book in further detail; please take a look at our re-read thoughts... remember Spoilers may be present!
SPOILER PAGE DISCUSSION LINK